THE DEATH OF A BOOKSTORE
In the past ten days there have been two articles of note in ‘The Times
Of India’ Hyderabad edition which serve as precursors to the obituaries that
would follow of the Bookstores that we have grown up with and got used to.
Sadly yes, it is like the death of a dear and near one and the grief that
follows. The first one on 25th March 2015 announced ‘Iconic City Bookstore To
Shut Down Shutters’. Since it is reported from Hyderabad anyone familiar with
the city will immediately be able to place it. “Shop in Abids to make way for
swanky shopping mall” the old makes place for the new, bringing an end to a
generation that found unbounded pleasure while browsing through the books stocked
neatly on dust free and polished shelves, and attended to by a knowledgeable
owner whose love for books seemed equal if not more than what you had prided
yourself with. AA Husain and Co. had been in existence the since the mid-forties
of the last century and was turned into a bookstore in 1949.
The report quotes the current owner “Since 2010, the footfalls at the
bookstore have dropped drastically. I believe it is because of the spurt of
online bookstores. People find it convenient to buy books at either bookstore
chains or online stores. Business for independent sellers is no longer
profitable.” While book lovers are obviously upset those who will be most hit
are the employees of the old store. Life will no longer be the same for them.
The second which appeared on the editorial page yesterday 4th
March 2015 is by Dileep Padgaonkar ‘Browse No More – Sad but inevitable
aftermath of the closure of a great bookshop’. He refers to iconic bookshops –
one in Pune, the International Book Service located in Deccan Gymkhana and the
other La Hune that has been operating in Paris since 1949 and known for its
famous clientele “This where the Surrealists led by their, guru, Andre Breton
congregated. On any given day you could spot celebrated writers, painters and
filmmakers – Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir, Picasso, Max Ernst, Truffaut,
Godard etc.- intently turning the pages of a book.” I also quote below the last
portion of the article by Padgaonkar that sort of sums it up –
“Some lament the ‘emasculation of culture’ and the ‘cancerous growth of
commercialism. Others stress the ‘inexorable logic of the market’ and the ‘democratisation
of reading’ in a digitalized universe.
What the closure of a good bookshop portends though can hardly be
denied. It deprives us of one of the gentler pleasures of life; Serendipity. This
allows you to browse through books at leisure in the hope of discovering quite
by chance, one that captivates your fancy.”
In this context I reproduce below a page from my book ‘I Am Just An
Ordinary Man’ –
“I have enjoyed browsing through the books in the bookshops, apart from
buying them. Though you have your Crosswords and Odysseys now, with their
stacks of books along with other items as a one stop buy, I miss the old
worldly charm of a Higginbotham at Madras or a Manney’s in Poona which were
dedicated to only books. But these were large stores. The books I bought in
Bombay were all from the pavement shop which you can still find when you walk
from Victoria Terminus to Flora Fountain. Many times I have stood there gazing
at the books. If what you were searching for was not available, the shopkeeper
would get it for you. I have walked those pavements any number of times when I
was in Bombay; during the day, during dusk and sometimes at night while going
back to the railway station to catch the train back home. But if I remember one
shop with special affection it was the ‘East West Bookshop’ in Baroda situated
in one of the interior roads. That is because of one kind old man. The shop was
small, his heart was big and his knowledge of books immense. Though he used to
deal with customers by just getting the books they wanted, for me he did that
little bit extra. He used to take me to the interiors of the shop and pull out
books which had been lying there untouched, but meant a lot to him. He knew I
was interested for he would then launch into a brief summary of the contents of
the book and recommend to me for reading. Perhaps the most valuable of my
acquisitions from there was a hard bound old edition of Schopenhauer’s The
World as Will and Idea. When I was transferred from Baroda and made my visit to
the shop before I left, he took me to the nearby hotel and bought me lunch.
That was his way of showing affection. He wished me all the luck and then I
left. I did visit the shop once or twice thereafter whenever I came down from
Ahmedabad. Of course I never left without buying a book. Well that was a
relationship and when I touched those books while cleaning them today, I
thought of him. I do not know whether he is there now, but I am pretty sure he
is not, for it has been nearly thirty five years since. I do not know whether
the shop exists, but if it does, then I am sure it will not be the quaint old
shop with a soul.”
Dileep Padgaonkar has aptly summed it up, and I have felt the same as a
lover of books. I have never found myself comfortable with an e-book. Even to
this day I like the book in my hand, to own it and find its rightful place in
the bookshelf. But I have woken up to certain realities as an author. There are
thousands of writers out there who struggle to see their book in print. Only a
miniscule are successful in getting a publisher to accept their manuscript,
which with any luck will be able to find its place in a bookstore. Stacking
books in a bookstore involves holding inventory and this involves cost which
the publisher does not want to risk for a debutant author. I have tackled the
problem of ‘The Writer’s Dilemma’ in my post of 27th July 2014 at http://subbusg.blogspot.in/2014/07/the-writers-dilemma.html
and earlier light hearted posts on the ‘Travails Of An Aspiring Author’. The
only way out for such writers is through having their books published by way of
self-publishing. There would be no rejections by publishing houses and the
costs would be under control as they would be POD print on demand. Anyway I
still have not understood the standards by which publishing houses accept or
reject manuscripts. Many books accepted and published by the publishing houses
have failed to take off, while a number of self-published authors have made it
big. So you see as a self-published
author the digital online stores have become a boon. I do whatever marketing is
possible through the social media and hope for the best, footfalls in a
bookstore do not ensure sales.
So you see my priorities as a book lover and an author are at
loggerheads. But to sum up I can only say that I would still like to see my
book on the shelf of a bookstore and watch surreptitiously with glee some customer
picking up the book and browsing through it
4 comments:
Getting into a bookstore has been my favourite pastime. Looking at the display, pulling out a book,grabbing a stool and sitting down to turn the pages is bliss. I can spend hours in a bookshop without getting tired. The closure of bookshops is sad, but then in these times of crass commercialisation what else can one expect. People do not have the time to sit at leisure and read a book. It is now on the go, so e books are more convenient. The romance of picking up a book, smelling the pages, turning every page, and then placing a book mark when you shut the book, are feelings of the past.
Yet, I am glad that people still do read books. The closure of book stores are like closure of parks where children used to play running around by themselves. Now a lot of children go to play areas in malls.
"The old order changeth yielding place to new".....
Buyers of books have probably been few and are getting even fewer. Just yesterday, I heard the veteran Marathi playwright, Mahesh Elkunchwar, rue that getting a thousand copies of his play sold in a year was an achievement. So, he added, he never wrote with this or that purpose, much less to sell. He wrote because he felt like writing. He even described his early days of staging plays when he and a few others would simply stage a play before an audience of a couple of hundred at best in the hall of a school. Once, he said, there were only two actors and just one in the audience!
- Kishor Kulkarni
Yes, the book stores are disappearing, but in their place, we have online fora that enable interaction in ways previously unimaginable. I mean, take this comment as an example: how often could a reader communicate directly with an author in the pre-internet era? I regularly follow the blogs of my favourite authors and see them respond to hundreds of comments, or conduct Reddit AMAs or do Google Hangouts or Youtube live chats, all of which allow way more people to talk to an author directly than the old book store signings. Overall, I think it is progress. Sure, I miss the smell of a physical book, but I think that's simply my need to indulge in nostalgia!
Post a Comment